What it is The Benebone Wishbone is a nylon-based chew toy designed specifically for aggressive chewers. Shaped like a wishbone, it features real bacon flavor embedded in the material to appeal to dogs. Made in the USA, it’s marketed as a long-lasting alternative to rawhide or softer chews. The medium size is intended for dogs up to about 50 pounds, though larger or smaller options are available. ## Key features to know - Nylon construction: The toy is made from a tough, food-grade nylon that’s harder than most plastic chews. This gives it durability against heavy chewing.

  • Real bacon flavor: The bacon is baked into the nylon, not just sprayed on, so the scent is stronger and lasts longer than surface-applied flavors.
  • Ergonomic wishbone shape: The curved design allows dogs to easily grip the toy with their paws and gnaw on the ends, which helps clean back teeth and provides a satisfying chewing angle.
  • Made in the USA: The company touts domestic manufacturing, which appeals to many owners concerned about overseas quality standards.
  • Odor and stain resistant: Nylon doesn’t absorb odors or stains as easily as softer materials like rubber or rope. ## Who it is best for This toy is best for moderate to aggressive chewers who enjoy gnawing on hard surfaces. It’s ideal for dogs that tend to destroy plush toys or softer chews quickly. The bacon flavor can be a strong motivator for picky dogs. It also works well for owners who want a toy that doesn’t get slimy or leave residue on furniture. The wishbone shape is particularly good for dogs that like to hold a toy between their paws while chewing. ## Things to consider before buying - Not for every aggressive chewer: While marketed for aggressive chewers, some dogs with exceptional jaw strength (like pit bulls or huskies) can break off pieces of nylon. These pieces can be sharp and pose a risk of intestinal blockage if swallowed. Always supervise the toy and discard it if it shows significant wear or splintering.
  • Hardness: The toy is very hard. Dogs with sensitive teeth or gums, or puppies teething, may find it uncomfortable. It’s not designed for teething puppies because it may be too abrasive on emerging adult teeth.
  • Bacon flavor fades: The flavor will gradually diminish over weeks of chewing. Some dogs lose interest once the taste is gone. The toy itself remains chewable, but without flavor, it’s just a hard nylon bone.
  • Potential for tooth damage: Hard nylon can cause tooth fractures in dogs that are very aggressive chewers. Watch for chipped teeth or signs of pain while chewing, and choose a softer option if your dog has had dental issues.
  • Size selection: The medium size is for dogs 20-50 pounds. For heavier chewers or larger breeds, consider the large. A too-small toy can be a choking hazard if ingested whole.
  • Not a fetch toy: This is meant for stationary chewing, not tossing or tugging. The hard material could hurt if thrown at a dog or person. ## Alternatives to consider - KONG Classic: A rubber toy that can be stuffed with treats. It’s softer than nylon and better for dogs that like to chew but also want some give. Best for moderate chewers; aggressive chewers may destroy it eventually.
  • Nylabone Dura Chew: Another nylon option with a bone shape, often textured for dental cleaning. Similar durability to Benebone but may have less flavor longevity.
  • Goughnuts Maxx 50: A heavy-duty rubber ring that’s virtually indestructible for most dogs. It’s non-toxic and has a safety indicator layer that shows when it’s time to replace. Softer on teeth than nylon.
  • West Paw Zogoflex Hurley: A tough, flexible chew toy that floats, so it’s good for water play. It’s EVA-based and softer than nylon, making it easier on teeth but less durable for extreme chewers.
  • Antlers or bones: Natural options like elk antlers or beef marrow bones are long-lasting but can also break teeth if too hard. They also have a strong odor and may cause splintering. Supervise always. Before buying, check the current price on Amazon to compare options.

Check current price on Amazon